Download Full Text (1.6 MB)


Fall 2012




When a building requires a long span, especially on the ground floor of a multi-story building, the long span often determines the structural system used early in the design pro-cess without any other consideration. Commercial and residential buildings are responsible for roughly 40% of all carbon emissions and energy use, more than any other sector in the USA. Moreover, this excludes the significant energy and emissions required to extract, process, trans-port and assemble building components. Globally, the production of cement alone accounts for 4% of carbon dioxide emissions. Consequently, reducing the environmental impact of building construction and operations is critical to address interrelated issues such as global climate change. The role of structural systems in the overall performance of a building has been largely neglected. Very little consideration is given to other ways the structure could contribute to improving sustainable outcomes. This is in spite of the fact that the structure of a typical office building contributes roughly one-quarter of the total embodied energy and is, at the very least, the armature for all other building systems. Existing research into the embodied energy of structural systems focuses on hypothetical office buildings with uniform structural layouts, a range of comparable, existing office buildings or housing without comparing or accounting for the long spans. Like all other aspects of a building, the structural system needs to be understood in terms of wide range of sustainability issues: embodied energy, operational energy, longevity and re-use. If structural systems could be left exposed without additional finishes as well as be configured to provide a higher level of thermal comfort, more daylight and acoustic isolation, this could significantly reduce Figure 1. Three long span floor systems considered in this study (left to right): concrete joists and post-tensioned concrete beams, steel wide-flange beams and girders, wood joists, glue-laminated beams and trusses. A fourth long span, post-tensioned concrete slab and beams, is not shown but is identical to the layout of the other concrete system without the joists. the operational energy and the initial materials required for new construction. These multi-performance structural systems, in contrast to high-performance structural materials that aim to only improve structural properties, offer considerable and largely untapped opportunities to improve new and existing buildings while potentially lowering construction costs. Using a five-story, 2,500 square-meter (27,000 square-foot) classroom building with 24.4 meters by 30.5 meters (80 feet by 100 feet) auditorium on the ground floor as a case study currently in design at Oregon State University, the multi-performance criteria for four long span systems, including steel, two concrete and wood, are compared (Figure 1). These criteria include embodied energy and carbon, structural and spatial properties, acoustic properties, fire protection and thermal properties. (Tables 1, 2 and 3).

This paper argues that the most efficient structural solution may not be the best in terms of overall sustainability outcomes, and the selection of a structural system should be based on multi-performance criteria. The objectives of this research is to inform integrated design teams during schematic design phases and project development processes to be more mindful of the performance of structural systems in terms of other aspects, including thermal, acoustic, environmental, and fire resistance, versus simply acting as the structure alone. One important criteria to add to this study would be the cost not just of the structural materials, but the cost for each system to meet certain acoustic, fire-rating and thermal criteria and the additional materials it would entail.


In Copyright. URI: This Item is protected by copyright and/or related rights. You are free to use this Item in any way that is permitted by the copyright and related rights legislation that applies to your use. For other uses you need to obtain permission from the rights-holder(s).

Persistent Identifier

A Multi-Performance Comparison of Long-Span Structural Systems

Included in

Architecture Commons